Dessert Pies
Cherry Lattice Pie
Sour Michigan cherries baked into the best buttery lattice crust you’ll ever have. The classic interwoven lattice top is a true American delight.
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Strawberries and tangy rhubarb in our buttery lattice crust.
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Apple Crumbly Pie
Caramelized spiced apples with a crumble top.
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Pecan Pie
Gooey, butterscotchy, and chock full of pecans this pie is baked with a whole lotta’ love in our signature butter crust.
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Pumpkin Pie
Seasonal. Available starting October
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Mississippi Mud Pie
Blueberries, blackberries and raspberries baked in our buttery lattice crust.
Individual: Must order at least 6 days in advance
9": Must order in advance
Apple Lattice Pie
Caramelized spiced apples baked until bubbly in our signature buttery crust.
Individual: Must order at least 6 days in advance
9": Must order in advance
Mississippi Mud Pie
Chocolate shortbread shell is filled with Belgian chocolate pudding, house-made marshmallow, brownie chunks, butterscotch swirls, and finished with two kinds of chocolate drizzle!
Individual: In store subject to availability
9": Must order in advance
Betty Berry's Crumble Pie
Blueberries, blackberries and raspberries with a crumble top.
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Chocolate Cookie Dough Pie
Two kinds of rich chocolate chips, and toffee bits, stud our gooey cookie dough, baked in a chocolate or shortbread crust...this pie will satisfy your inner cookie monster!
Individual: In store subject to availability
9": Must Order In Advance
Ley Lime Pie
Fresh squeezed lime juice is “KEY” to our fabulously tangy custard, baked into our homemade graham shell, this pie is sure to be a hit!
Individual and 9": In store subject to availability
Banana Cream Pie
Vanilla bean custard, fresh bananas in a banana graham cracker crust. Finished with our own whipped cream topping.
Individual: In store subject to availability
9": Must order in advance